Abaqus vs MSC PATRAN [EOL] comparison

Finite Element Analysis (FEA) reaches the desk of the engineering analyst as a software package. Unless that software has been designed to exploit the true generality of the method, the analyst will become frustrated by the gap between the method's theoretical potential and the unnecessary limitations imposed by the software. This is where Abaqus shines. Abaqus is truly a general-purpose finite element-based software package.

With an extensive library of element types, it can model nearly any geometry. Abaqus has an equally extensive library of material models that can simulate stress and deformation in isotropic and anisotropic metals at low and high temperatures, at low and high strain rates, and at small and large strains. Beyond metals, Abaqus can simulate rubber and polymers, reinforced concrete, glass and ceramics, crushable or resilient foam, and geotechnical materials like soils and rock.

However, Abaqus offers more than just stress analysis. With Abaqus, you can simulate conductive and convective heat transfer, mass diffusion, acoustics, piezoelectricity, and electrochemistry either independently, sequentially coupled, or fully coupled with the stress analysis. What makes Abaqus uniquely powerful is its modularity. You can model any physically reasonable combination of elements, materials, procedures, and loading sequences. Any material can be used with virtually any element (or, in the case of composites, in a layer of an element) and thus form a part of a model subjected to any sequence of static or dynamic loading histories.

Finite element simulation of large models

The need for a detailed understanding of designs increases with the complexity of those designs. This in turn leads to the requirement for large simulation models. The FEA system must allow the analyst to run very large problems easily while efficiently leveraging available computer resources. Abaqus takes advantage of the high-performance features of modern computers, so model size limitations rarely prevent you from realizing an adequate simulation. Users appreciate being able to meet schedules because the code runs large, complex jobs through to completion. Realistic models quickly expose how well the code’s designers took care of the details. Abaqus holds up under the rigors of real-life, large model requirements.

Simulation of nonlinearity

More and more frequently, the analyst must consider nonlinear response as an essential part of a simulation. Lightweight structures buckle; in accident scenarios, they may collapse. Some important modern materials — like rubbers and plastics — are too soft to simulate based on linearized deformation. Often the designer wishes to take full advantage of the ductility and toughness of the materials available. Many design problems involve contact, from Hertz contact in bearing design to general sliding contact between a part and the die or mold used to form it, or between two parts, each undergoing substantial deformation. Abaqus has been designed from its beginning to address these types of problems. This has led to its worldwide reputation as the tool of choice for simulations where nonlinearity dominates the response.

Simplicity of use in complex problems

The popularity of Abaqus as an advanced analysis code is based on its focus on production analysis. Despite its great breadth of capabilities, Abaqus is easy to learn and use. Because it is modular and has simple, consistent, and intuitive problem definition rules, you are freed from artificial and frustrating limitations. You can model geometry as closely as needed, define material behaviors associated with the various components of the model, and simulate a sequence of events of concern. At no time will the code limit this process unnecessarily. As far as possible, Abaqus relieves you of difficult tasks. One of the best examples is automatic time stepping in nonlinear static, dynamic, and heat transfer problems: Abaqus chooses and continuously adjusts the time increments automatically. This feature alone has permitted many users to perform simulations that would have been impossible otherwise. You can tackle realistic simulations with confidence of success and with the assurance of meeting design schedules.

Research organizations use Abaqus extensively because of its versatility and user-defined extensibility. But its great success has been built on its acceptance in the design analysis community as a general analysis tool that not only provides convenience in routine simulations but greatly extends the range of possible simulations.

What distinguishes Abaqus is its proven record of success in the largest and most complex problems. If you face relatively straightforward applications, you will find Abaqus a pleasure to use. If you are facing very challenging problems, you will come to rely on Abaqus as the one tool that provides reliable answers.

Patran is the world's most widely used pre/post-processing software for Finite Element Analysis (FEA), providing solid modeling, meshing, analysis setup and post-processing for multiple solvers including MSC Nastran, Marc, Abaqus, LS-DYNA, ANSYS, and Pam-Crash.