Managing Consultant - Data Management Services and GDPR at a tech services company with 10,001+ employees
Real User
Oct 4, 2017
Hi,
I can’t help re Delphix but see below for IBM Optim and Informatica archive solutions.
Need archival software comparison for IBM OPTIM,Informatica ILM, Delphix.
- What database it will support?
Both IBM and Informatica will support all the main DBs, mainframe and distributed.
IBM have a tool called Federated server which helps connect to any obscure databases you may have. Informatica might need a little more fiddling and has had issues around connecting to obscure
data sources.
Both are now archiving unstructured data but be careful around cloud (SFDC etc), they may not be as far ahead as they claim. Try before you buy.
SAP can be a problem.
- Performance
Would not choose one over the other re performance. To an extent it’s down to the kit you provide and often clients look to save here especially where kit performance affects license.
- System Requirements
Again similar although the Informatica solution may have higher needs, probably looking at a min 8 core server to run the software. Often clients are looking at cheapest option they can get away with.
Will need at least 1 repository data base created which has to be either DB2, Oracle or SQL server. Might need a separate server for that.
Compression rates are excellent for both.
Both will need storage for archive files.
I recommend getting a detailed breakdown on the infrastructure required up front and how it might impact performance.
- Cost
You are likely looking at 6 figure sums for both, also think about services for getting you going which is likely a 4-6 week project.
If you buy at an end of quarter you might get better discounts.
They may be licensed slightly differently from IBM to Infa so comparing like for like may need some investigation.
- Support
Interesting one in both cases. Informatica have been running down both development and support for Archiving which was a bought in product and does not integrate with its Powercenter toolset. IBM
have ‘outsourced’ development and support for Optim.
I would be more worried about Informatica at this point.
- Recommendation to use which one and why
I would tend towards IBM but make sure you understand whats happening re development and support moving forwards.
I would definitely get a PoC run to prove it can achieve your main (especially obscure) requirements. Surprise Surprise Sales will promise the earth but the reality can be very different especially
around connecting to certain Data sources.
Neither tool is aimed at users, you will need a techy. You can automate many of the processes but will need ongoing BAU/management.
Director, Customer & C-suite Programs at a tech vendor with 201-500 employees
Vendor
Oct 19, 2017
Hello,
This from the 2016 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Structured Data Archiving and Application Retirement on Delphix, who was a Leader in that MQ along with IBM and Informatica. I updated a few things such as our headquarter move and anything else that was dated. I'd be happy to send you the full report if you'd like - just let me know.
-----------------------------------------------
Delphix, headquartered in Redwood City, California, offers the Delphix Dynamic Data
platform. The platform supports Oracle E-business Suite, PeopleSoft, Siebel, JD Edwards, Baan and SAP application environments, as well as IBM DB2, Oracle, SQL Server and other databases. The offering works through copy data management, meaning it creates and manages virtualized copies of the database/application environment and provides management controls, including retention and access, as part of the life cycle. Delphix has recently seen an upsurge in SAP archiving opportunities, and is providing governance and data modeling capabilities to support financial services for Dodd-Frank compliance initiatives. Delphix is largely sold by a direct sales force
through which pricing is offered in server- and term-based models. Support for DB2 on z/OS and SAP Hana are on the roadmap.
Delphix announced in 2017 partnerships with AWS and Azure for accelerating data migration to the cloud. In Gartner's Data Masking Magic Quadrant, Delphix was recognized as THE ONLY solution solving for masking and data distribution challenges. Hope that helps.
Find out what your peers are saying about IBM InfoSphere Optim Test Data Management (TDM) vs. Perforce Delphix and other solutions. Updated: January 2026.
Perforce Delphix and IBM InfoSphere Optim Test Data Management compete in test data management solutions. IBM InfoSphere Optim TDM has the upper hand due to its extensive features and enterprise integration, despite Perforce Delphix's favorable pricing and support. Features: Perforce Delphix focuses on efficient data virtualization, fast provisioning, and automated data masking to enhance speed and security. IBM InfoSphere Optim TDM provides comprehensive data archiving, seamless enterprise...
Hi,
I can’t help re Delphix but see below for IBM Optim and Informatica archive solutions.
Need archival software comparison for IBM OPTIM,Informatica ILM, Delphix.
- What database it will support?
Both IBM and Informatica will support all the main DBs, mainframe and distributed.
IBM have a tool called Federated server which helps connect to any obscure databases you may have. Informatica might need a little more fiddling and has had issues around connecting to obscure
data sources.
Both are now archiving unstructured data but be careful around cloud (SFDC etc), they may not be as far ahead as they claim. Try before you buy.
SAP can be a problem.
- Performance
Would not choose one over the other re performance. To an extent it’s down to the kit you provide and often clients look to save here especially where kit performance affects license.
- System Requirements
Again similar although the Informatica solution may have higher needs, probably looking at a min 8 core server to run the software. Often clients are looking at cheapest option they can get away with.
Will need at least 1 repository data base created which has to be either DB2, Oracle or SQL server. Might need a separate server for that.
Compression rates are excellent for both.
Both will need storage for archive files.
I recommend getting a detailed breakdown on the infrastructure required up front and how it might impact performance.
- Cost
You are likely looking at 6 figure sums for both, also think about services for getting you going which is likely a 4-6 week project.
If you buy at an end of quarter you might get better discounts.
They may be licensed slightly differently from IBM to Infa so comparing like for like may need some investigation.
- Support
Interesting one in both cases. Informatica have been running down both development and support for Archiving which was a bought in product and does not integrate with its Powercenter toolset. IBM
have ‘outsourced’ development and support for Optim.
I would be more worried about Informatica at this point.
- Recommendation to use which one and why
I would tend towards IBM but make sure you understand whats happening re development and support moving forwards.
I would definitely get a PoC run to prove it can achieve your main (especially obscure) requirements. Surprise Surprise Sales will promise the earth but the reality can be very different especially
around connecting to certain Data sources.
Neither tool is aimed at users, you will need a techy. You can automate many of the processes but will need ongoing BAU/management.
Hello,
This from the 2016 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Structured Data Archiving and Application Retirement on Delphix, who was a Leader in that MQ along with IBM and Informatica. I updated a few things such as our headquarter move and anything else that was dated. I'd be happy to send you the full report if you'd like - just let me know.
-----------------------------------------------
Delphix, headquartered in Redwood City, California, offers the Delphix Dynamic Data
platform. The platform supports Oracle E-business Suite, PeopleSoft, Siebel, JD Edwards, Baan and SAP application environments, as well as IBM DB2, Oracle, SQL Server and other databases. The offering works through copy data management, meaning it creates and manages virtualized copies of the database/application environment and provides management controls, including retention and access, as part of the life cycle. Delphix has recently seen an upsurge in SAP archiving opportunities, and is providing governance and data modeling capabilities to support financial services for Dodd-Frank compliance initiatives. Delphix is largely sold by a direct sales force
through which pricing is offered in server- and term-based models. Support for DB2 on z/OS and SAP Hana are on the roadmap.
Delphix announced in 2017 partnerships with AWS and Azure for accelerating data migration to the cloud. In Gartner's Data Masking Magic Quadrant, Delphix was recognized as THE ONLY solution solving for masking and data distribution challenges. Hope that helps.