Jun 03, 2021
Panaya and Tricentis are both good. Could you share more info on your use case and what are your key selection criteria ?
Tricentis Tosca and Panaya Test Dynamix are leading automation testing platforms. Tricentis Tosca holds an edge in flexibility and advanced capabilities, appealing to complex environments, whereas Panaya Test Dynamix is preferred for its SAP integration benefits.
Features: Tricentis Tosca offers model-based testing, diverse testing methods, and cross-platform support. It includes rapid and effective automation capabilities with a scriptless approach and support for multiple UI and non-UI technologies. Panaya Test Dynamix is tailored for its change impact analysis and risk-free updates, which are critical for SAP-centric processes. Its seamless integration with SAP applications provides specialized insights for industries relying heavily on SAP systems.
Room for Improvement: Tricentis Tosca could enhance its deployment model to simplify initial configurations, improve its reporting features, and integrate better with non-Test Management tools. Panaya Test Dynamix may benefit from expanding its capabilities beyond SAP-centric operations, enhancing cross-functional compatibility, and improving its UI for non-SAP users to increase its versatility.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Tricentis Tosca has a complex deployment model with robust support services, catering to detailed configuration needs. Panaya Test Dynamix features a smoother deployment process, especially in SAP environments, with a customer service approach focused on rapid resolution of issues, ensuring efficient setup and operation.
Pricing and ROI: Tricentis Tosca involves higher initial investments but offers potential high ROI due to its expansive automation efficiencies. In contrast, Panaya Test Dynamix presents a more cost-effective solution for SAP applications, promising faster ROI with optimized updates and reduced testing errors, specifically in environments where SAP integration is key.
Tasks that typically take ten hours are reduced to two to three hours, representing a threefold productivity gain.
The overall competence of the support has declined; previously, the support was very good, but recently, it has become difficult to reach them and get solutions, and it's taking a lot of time.
My experience has been positive; their response to emails or phone calls in tech support is fast, usually between eight to ten hours.
There is no way to mark the importance or criticality of incidents when creating them.
It covers a breadth of applications and products, demonstrating excellent scalability that I have seen in reality.
Scalability is excellent with Tricentis Tosca.
For performance and stability, Tricentis Tosca deserves a 10 out of 10.
The stability of Tricentis Tosca is rated ten out of ten. It is very stable.
I find stability issues when using the Vision AI feature; Tricentis Tosca is not very stable.
The self-healing process should automatically handle any changes in web applications; for instance, if properties change inside the application, the tool should automatically take care of it, unlike other tools such as Mabl and TestComplete that have better self-healing capabilities.
The Vision AI implementation works very slowly, affecting the speed of our work.
Moving to a cloud-based application rather than a desktop one could improve Tosca.
The pricing for Tricentis Tosca is extremely high, and I rate it as ten in terms of expense.
A yearly license costs around 20,000 euros.
For enterprise customers, the cost is manageable because it provides solutions for multiple applications they want to automate.
It allows for drag-and-drop functionality and demo automation in SAP-based applications, which can be challenging with other automation tools.
The features I find most valuable in Tricentis Tosca are that it's the easiest way to build the scripts and to do the CI/CD process; using Tricentis Tosca is very useful and easy.
The modular approach reduces scripting effort by at least fifty percent, which significantly cuts down on the script development time.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Tricentis Tosca | 12.0% |
| Panaya Test Dynamix | 2.1% |
| Other | 85.9% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 23 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 24 |
| Large Enterprise | 72 |
Panaya Test Dynamix makes it easy for large enterprises to test smarter and release faster, by gaining control and visibility of every aspect of their ERP testing wherever they are.
With SAP ERP testing holding unique challenges, Test Dynamix offers provides all test management and execution capabilities in a single place , with a business process-centered approach designed specifically for SAP and Oracle testing, risk-based testing and test automation, to ensure the most efficient and effective large-scale testing possible.
Tricentis Tosca offers model-based testing that supports both technical and non-technical users through a user-friendly interface, enabling scriptless automation and seamless integration with UI and non-UI applications.
Tosca's modular approach enhances test maintenance and reuse while delivering comprehensive automation for diverse testing environments. Backed by risk-based testing and automated data management, it supports end-to-end testing across API, SAP, and desktop applications. Tosca's integration capabilities extend to environments like Salesforce, PHP webshops, and mobile apps, effectively enhancing Agile team workflows. Despite its strengths, room remains for improved reporting, object recognition, and more efficient upgrade processes. Enhancing documentation and mobile testing support could further elevate its functionality for many.
What key features does Tricentis Tosca offer?In retail, Tricentis Tosca automates inventory and transaction testing, ensuring efficient system updates. Financial services employ it for regulatory compliance through automated test scenarios in mainframe and PDF environments. Telecommunication companies utilize Tosca for API testing, aligning services across network platforms seamlessly.
We monitor all Functional Testing Tools reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
