Executive SummaryUpdated on Dec 5, 2024
Arbor DDoS and F5 BIG-IP Advanced Firewall Manager compete in the DDoS protection and network security category. Arbor has the upper hand in user-friendliness and traffic visibility, while F5 AFM excels in integration with other F5 modules.
Features: Arbor DDoS includes predefined filters for easy attack mitigation, cloud signaling for coordination between on-premises and service provider protection, and real-time threat intelligence for proactive defense. Its hybrid approach provides multi-layer protection. F5 BIG-IP AFM offers unified network security by integrating with other F5 solutions, advanced WAF capabilities for robust application defense, and simplifies management with its modular integration.
Room for Improvement: Arbor DDoS users seek improvements in auto-mitigation features, scalability of hardware, and better third-party integration. They also suggest enhancements in reporting and reducing false positives. F5 AFM could benefit from a simpler user interface, improved reporting, and enhanced automation capabilities. Customers also desire more intuitive configuration logic and better integration with BIG-IQ.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Arbor DDoS supports on-premises and hybrid cloud deployments and is known for its good technical support, though response times vary by region. F5 AFM also supports both deployment models, with responsive customer service noted for occasional delays. Both products offer strong technical expertise, with Arbor noted for deep product knowledge.
Pricing and ROI: Arbor DDoS is regarded as high-performing but expensive compared to competitors, with costs related to enterprise throughput and managed routers. Its clear licensing is a positive, though overall expenses are a concern. F5 AFM, while also costly, provides value through integrated features. Both deliver significant ROI by mitigating costly DDoS attacks and ensuring service uptime.
