

Fortinet FortiNAC and ExtremeControl are competing network access control solutions. ExtremeControl has the upper hand due to its comprehensive features.
Features: Fortinet FortiNAC offers robust automation, scalability, and extensive visibility across network environments. ExtremeControl provides in-depth integration capabilities, flexible policy management, and precise threat response mechanisms.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Fortinet FortiNAC presents a straightforward deployment process with prompt customer service. ExtremeControl has a more complex setup but offers responsive and knowledgeable support that enhances long-term system management.
Pricing and ROI: Fortinet FortiNAC has lower setup costs and a promising return on investment for budget-conscious businesses. ExtremeControl may have a higher initial cost, but its advanced capabilities justify the expenses, offering substantial long-term value.
Having good connectivity through Wi-Fi is essential for the entire business.
We have saved resources and time, and we have also secured our network, confirming we have a return on investment.
For technical support of ExtremeControl, I have no doubts that they cope with problems effectively.
They do not offer straightforward support if there is an issue unless we upgrade.
They provide sessions to help with various questions.
Fortinet FortiNAC's customer support is very good, as is typical from Fortinet.
They could do more to improve, not because of the product itself but because of the support they provide.
For scalability in larger environments, it can be rated a maximum of 10.
The pricing model makes it challenging as the cost is substantial due to the per-node licensing model.
For their wired network, especially with third-party switching, this is where most of the features are lost.
There is also another product called UZTNA, which is said to have NAC in this solution, but it is not as advanced as our regular ExtremeControl.
We rely more on the cloud for analytics rather than on-premise, and some customers prefer relying on an on-premise solution rather than a cloud solution.
Improvement in the interface design would make FortiNAC a better solution.
Fortinet FortiNAC can be improved as the GUI is very poor compared to other competitors such as Cisco ISE.
The graphical user interface (GUI) of Fortinet FortiNAC is very poor compared to competitors like Forcepoint and Cisco ISE.
Compared to other competitors, they have the best pricing.
Below this number, we are not competitive with other vendors.
The pricing of ExtremeControl is considerable; I would rate it at eight or nine.
My experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing for Fortinet FortiNAC is that, as is typical from Fortinet, all their products have a very good licensing model and competitive pricing.
Fortinet FortiNAC is relatively cheap compared to other solutions.
The biggest benefits for my customers from ExtremeControl include the ability to integrate third-party devices, integration with user databases like Microsoft Active Directory or other directory software, and it is easy to maintain by customers.
The most effective feature of ExtremeControl is that whenever any user is connected through the network, I can really dig down and check exactly what applications they have been using.
Integrating ExtremeControl with ExtremeConnect provides an additional layer of security and control over what devices are onboarding to the network, granting full visibility.
I appreciate the feature where it can connect with different vendor equipment, regardless of the network devices from other vendors.
Fortinet FortiNAC has positively impacted my organization by allowing us to control our network and save time.
The main advantage of Fortinet FortiNAC is its integration with the entire Fortinet product portfolio.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Fortinet FortiNAC | 14.5% |
| ExtremeControl | 2.5% |
| Other | 83.0% |

| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 3 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 3 |
| Large Enterprise | 3 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 30 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 14 |
| Large Enterprise | 14 |
ExtremeControl delivers efficient end-user activity recognition and traffic monitoring, valued for its user-friendliness, flexibility, and strong third-party integration. It secures mobile environments reliably and consistently, aiding in detailed application monitoring and troubleshooting.
ExtremeControl provides seamless security integration, recognized for its capacity to seamlessly incorporate user databases and third-party devices, ensuring enhanced and reliable security. The comprehensive features, backed by straightforward documentation and implementation processes, support the detailed monitoring of application traffic, which assists in troubleshooting. It is not without areas for development, particularly in on-premises controllers that could benefit from more features and options. Additional control over network traffic and improved product integration, especially with certificate management and cloud analytics, are desirable enhancements.
What are the key features of ExtremeControl?ExtremeControl is commonly implemented in educational institutions and enterprises, managing user identities and network security, integrating Active Directory, and supporting BYOD policies. It enables custom device authentication, setting policies for internal network access and quarantining unauthorized devices. Organizations benefit from seamless third-party integration, supporting secure network environments.
Fortinet FortiNAC is integral for enhancing network access control by providing security, visibility, and control over IoT devices. Known for its user-friendly interface and powerful automation, it streamlines network management and access control while supporting policy enforcement and guest management.
Fortinet FortiNAC offers robust security by integrating seamlessly with Fortinet products, enhancing compatibility with external vendors, and allowing users to manage wired and wireless networks efficiently. Known for its ability to prevent unauthorized connections, it enhances network visibility and control, particularly in managing Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) and compliance. However, integration with non-Fortinet systems, better reporting capabilities, and intuitive interface improvements are areas for enhancement. Setup complexities, additional equipment needs for features like single sign-on, and improved support and documentation are noted challenges.
What are the key features of Fortinet FortiNAC?In education and healthcare, Fortinet FortiNAC is applied extensively to manage Wi-Fi access for non-domain devices, ensuring secure network access without traditional password-based systems. It integrates with Fortinet Security Fabric, offering endpoint profiling and posture assessments to ensure adherence to security standards. This implementation enhances BYOD management, allowing organizations to meet compliance and security requirements effectively across diverse environments.
We monitor all Network Access Control (NAC) reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.