HCL AppScan vs Klocwork comparison

HCLSoftware and Perforce are both solutions in the Application Security Tools category. HCLSoftware is ranked #15 with an average rating of 8.3, while Perforce is ranked #19 with an average rating of 8.2. HCLSoftware holds a 2.5% mindshare in AS, compared to Perforce’s 1.4% mindshare. Additionally, 84% of HCLSoftware users are willing to recommend the solution, compared to 93% of Perforce users who would recommend it.

HCL AppScan

Read 43 HCL AppScan reviews

4,377 Views
3,108 Comparison Views

84% willing to recommend

Klocwork

Read 25 Klocwork reviews

3,353 Views
1,878 Comparison Views

93% willing to recommend

HCL AppScan

Klocwork

Comparison Buyer's Guide

Download the report

Executive SummaryUpdated on Oct 8, 2024

HCL AppScan and Klocwork compete in the software security and code analysis category. HCL AppScan seems to have the upper hand in support and pricing, while Klocwork is preferred for its advanced features.

Features: HCL AppScan offers extensive security testing capabilities, multiple integration options, and a user-friendly interface for a variety of applications. Klocwork provides advanced static code analysis, supports a wide range of coding languages, and offers comprehensive reporting features.

Room for Improvement: HCL AppScan needs to improve analysis speed, reduce false positives, and enhance user interface for usability. Klocwork could improve user experience with simplified setup processes, more intuitive navigation, and reducing resource consumption during analysis.

Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: HCL AppScan is recognized for straightforward deployment options and responsive customer service. Klocwork is effective in deployment but could benefit from offering more proactive and readily available support.

Pricing and ROI: HCL AppScan is competitively priced with good ROI as reported by users, offering a wide range of features at accessible pricing. Klocwork, though potentially more expensive, delivers value through robust features and is often worth its cost for companies requiring sophisticated code analysis capabilities.

To learn more, read our detailed HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork Report (Updated: September 2025).

Buyer's Guide

HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork

September 2025

Download the complete report

Helped 868,787 peers since 2012

Review summaries and opinions

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said:

ROI

Sentiment score

2.1

HCL AppScan enhances architecture with fewer errors and improved security, achieving 50% return and 20% cost savings.

Sentiment score

6.2

Klocwork enhances code quality and compliance, improving efficiency in defect resolution, especially in automotive sectors, despite ROI measurement challenges.

No quotes available

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

The main ROI factors include efficiency and how we meet compliance standards for various automotive requirements.

Krishna M Gopalakrishnan

Manager, Quality, Functional Safety, Cybersecurity Embedded Processing at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Customer Service

Sentiment score

5.4

HCL AppScan's support is responsive with mixed reviews, facing regional challenges and lagging behind competitors like Veracode.

Sentiment score

6.8

Klocwork's support is praised for responsiveness, effective problem-solving, and reducing user contact via comprehensive documentation, despite prioritization issues.

Veracode provides excellent assistance and regularly scheduled calls to address customer concerns and updates.

MukeshSaha

Associate Principal, Software Engineering at LTI - Larsen & Toubro Infotech

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

The issue is not about the knowledge of the support but about the prioritization of the tickets they handle.

Krishna M Gopalakrishnan

Manager, Quality, Functional Safety, Cybersecurity Embedded Processing at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

The customer support team is very responsive, proactive, and engages in conversations to ensure our needs are met.

AlexanderAgranovsky

Application Development Team Lead at Miura Pay

During the initial phase when I did interact with the vendor, the support was satisfactory.

Pranay Mishra

Director - Quality Excellence at a manufacturing company with 501-1,000 employees

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Scalability Issues

Sentiment score

4.9

HCL AppScan is scalable yet varies by license, integration issues, infrastructure compatibility, and CI/CD pipeline design effectiveness.

Sentiment score

6.7

Klocwork is scalable, efficient, and integrates well with SAST tools, suitable for teams of all sizes without scalability issues.

No quotes available

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

Klocwork supports our scalability needs without issues, even as project volumes increase.

AlexanderAgranovsky

Application Development Team Lead at Miura Pay

The program-to-program enablement is scalable.

Pranay Mishra

Director - Quality Excellence at a manufacturing company with 501-1,000 employees

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Stability Issues

Sentiment score

6.8

HCL AppScan is stable and reliable, with minor hardware issues, improved by recent upgrades enhancing performance and stability.

Sentiment score

6.8

Klocwork is reliable and stable, effectively handling large codebases but requires significant computing power and faster updates.

No quotes available

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

Installation is easy, and the solution is stable.

Gururaj-Rao

Integration Supervisor Lead at Visteon Corporation

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Room For Improvement

HCL AppScan requires improvements in vulnerability detection, usability, integration, performance, support, pricing, and language/codebase compatibility to stay competitive.

Klocwork needs improved language support, flexible reporting, better integration with Agile DevOps, and enhanced static and dynamic analysis.

No quotes available

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

We would like Klocwork to connect to Git and notify developers of issues tied to specific commits.

AlexanderAgranovsky

Application Development Team Lead at Miura Pay

Klocwork should be able to analyze large codebases efficiently, supporting a desktop version for periodic small delta changes before pushing to the server.

Krishna M Gopalakrishnan

Manager, Quality, Functional Safety, Cybersecurity Embedded Processing at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

Klocwork sometimes provides too many additional warnings which require expertise to manage.

Pranay Mishra

Director - Quality Excellence at a manufacturing company with 501-1,000 employees

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Setup Cost

HCL AppScan is considered expensive but cost-effective, with varied pricing opinions influenced by its premium features and discounts.

Klocwork's flexible pricing models are valued, though opinions vary on cost-effectiveness, catering to diverse organizational needs.

Companies often choose based on budget constraints, with Veracode being on the higher end cost-wise.

MukeshSaha

Associate Principal, Software Engineering at LTI - Larsen & Toubro Infotech

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

It is less expensive than Coverity.

Pranay Mishra

Director - Quality Excellence at a manufacturing company with 501-1,000 employees

The solution is not very cheap, however, it is less expensive than Coverity.

Gururaj-Rao

Integration Supervisor Lead at Visteon Corporation

Klocwork's pricing seems attractive, as it uses a per-user license model that does not have a lot of overhead.

Krishna M Gopalakrishnan

Manager, Quality, Functional Safety, Cybersecurity Embedded Processing at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Valuable Features

HCL AppScan detects vulnerabilities, integrates with agile processes, offers scalability, user-friendly features, and AI-enhanced rapid scanning for security.

Klocwork provides efficient static code analysis with strong IDE integration, supporting multiple languages and enhancing code quality and collaboration.

AppScan's most valuable features include its ability to identify vulnerabilities accurately, provide detailed remediation steps, and the newly introduced AI-powered features that enhance its functionality further.

MukeshSaha

Associate Principal, Software Engineering at LTI - Larsen & Toubro Infotech

For more quotes and insights, download the HCL AppScan report

Its integration with the CI/CD pipeline has helped streamline the software development process.

Krishna M Gopalakrishnan

Manager, Quality, Functional Safety, Cybersecurity Embedded Processing at a manufacturing company with 10,001+ employees

The most valuable feature of Klocwork is the static analysis tools, which help identify potential security threats and errors.

AlexanderAgranovsky

Application Development Team Lead at Miura Pay

It takes just half a day to set up.

Gururaj-Rao

Integration Supervisor Lead at Visteon Corporation

For more quotes and insights, download the Klocwork report

Categories and Ranking

HCL AppScan

Ranking in Application Security Tools

15th

Ranking in Static Application Security Testing (SAST)

14th

Average Rating

7.8

Reviews Sentiment

5.9

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST) (1st)

Klocwork

Ranking in Application Security Tools

19th

Ranking in Static Application Security Testing (SAST)

17th

Average Rating

8.0

Reviews Sentiment

6.8

Number of Reviews

Ranking in other categories

Static Code Analysis (6th)

Mindshare comparison

As of October 2025, in the Application Security Tools category, the mindshare of HCL AppScan is 2.5%, down from 2.6% compared to the previous year. The mindshare of Klocwork is 1.4%, down from 1.5% compared to the previous year. It is calculated based on PeerSpot user engagement data.

Application Security Tools Market Share Distribution
Product	Market Share (%)
HCL AppScan	2.5%
Klocwork	1.4%
Other	96.1%

Application Security Tools

Featured Reviews

Gladwin Christian

QA manager at SmartStream Technologies ltd.

A useful tool to scan applications that can be easily installed

Given that we have been using HCL AppScan for many years, I think the setup process is not difficult at all. Sometimes, some issues stop or prevent my company from moving forward with the product's setup phase. We have to call HCL's support team and engage in long discussions to smoothly carry out the setup phase. In general, the product's setup phase is not difficult in our company. The solution is deployed on an on-premises model. The licenses for the solution are available only on cloud deployments nowadays. The solution is already installed in our environment. Every time a new release or software comes out from HCL, our company does a scan, which takes maybe a day or two.

Read full review

AnirbanSarkar

Head - Solution Management Group at Meteonic Innovation Pvt. Ltd.

Lets you find defects during the development phase, so you don't have to wait till the development is over to find and address flaws

What needs improvement in Klocwork, compared to other products in the market, is the dashboard or reporting mechanisms that need to be a bit more flexible. The Klocwork dashboard could be improved. Though it's good, it's not as good as some of the other products in the market, which is a problem. The reporting could be more detailed and easier to sort out because sorting in Klocwork could be a bit more time-consuming, mainly when sorting defects based on filters, compared to how it's done on other tools such as Coverity. What I'd like added in the next release of Klocwork is the peer code review Cahoots which used to be a part of Klocwork, and the architecture analysis and both have been taken out of Klocwork. I found the two critical for specific deployments, so if those can be brought back to Klocwork, that would be very good.

Read full review

See which vendors are best for you

Use our free recommendation engine to learn which Application Security Tools solutions are best for your needs.

See recommendations

868,787 professionals have used our research since 2012.

Top Industries

By visitors reading reviews

Computer Software Company

15%

Financial Services Firm

12%

Government

10%

Manufacturing Company

10%

Manufacturing Company

26%

Computer Software Company

12%

Comms Service Provider

Transportation Company

Company Size

By reviewers

Large Enterprise

Midsize Enterprise

Small Business

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	13
Midsize Enterprise	6
Large Enterprise	31

By reviewers
Company Size	Count
Small Business	12
Midsize Enterprise	2
Large Enterprise	12

Questions from the Community

What do you like most about HCL AppScan?

The most valuable feature of HCL AppScan is its integration with the SDLC, particularly during the coding phase.

See all answers

What needs improvement with HCL AppScan?

AppScan needs to improve its handling of false positives. It also requires enhancements in customer support, similar to what Veracode provides. Regularly scheduling calls with clients to discuss fe...

See all answers

What is your primary use case for HCL AppScan?

The primary use case for AppScan is for security purposes. I compare AppScan with other tools such as Veracode. We use AppScan for vulnerability detection and auto-remediation of vulnerabilities wi...

See all answers

What is your experience regarding pricing and costs for Klocwork?

Klocwork's pricing seems attractive, as it uses a per-user license model that does not have a lot of overhead.

See all answers

What needs improvement with Klocwork?

One area for improvement is that when customers use different static analysis tools, they report more issues compared to Klocwork. The static analysis engine of Klocwork has areas that need improve...

See all answers

What is your primary use case for Klocwork?

I work on tools such as Klocwork, LDRA, as well as Jira and Confluence, focusing more on the software quality assurance aspect. We use Klocwork for coding and aggregate checks. We use it for static...

See all answers

Comparisons

SonarQube Server (formerly SonarQube) vs HCL AppScan

Compared 12% of the time

Acunetix vs HCL AppScan

Compared 11% of the time

Veracode vs HCL AppScan

Compared 11% of the time

OWASP Zap vs HCL AppScan

Compared 8% of the time

PortSwigger Burp Suite Professional vs HCL AppScan

Compared 7% of the time

More HCL AppScan Competitors

Coverity Static vs Klocwork

Compared 28% of the time

SonarQube Server (formerly SonarQube) vs Klocwork

Compared 27% of the time

Polyspace Code Prover vs Klocwork

Compared 14% of the time

Helix QAC vs Klocwork

Compared 6% of the time

Axivion Static Code Analysis vs Klocwork

Compared 6% of the time

More Klocwork Competitors

Product Reports

Buyer's Guide

HCL AppScan

September 2025

Download HCL AppScan product report

Buyer's Guide

Klocwork

September 2025

Download Klocwork product report

Also Known As

IBM Security AppScan, Rational AppScan, AppScan

No data available

Overview

IBM Security AppScan enhances web application security and mobile application security, improves application security program management and strengthens regulatory compliance. By scanning your web and mobile applications prior to deployment, AppScan enables you to identify security vulnerabilities and generate reports and fix recommendations.

HCLSoftware

Klocwork detects security, safety, and reliability issues in real-time by using this static code analysis toolkit that works alongside developers, finding issues as early as possible, and integrates with teams, supporting continuous integration and actionable reporting.

Perforce

Sample Customers

Essex Technology Group Inc., Cisco, West Virginia University, APIS IT

ACCESS Co Ltd, Risk-AI, Winbond Electronics, Bristol-Myers Squibb Pharmaceutical Research Institute, University of Southern California, Alebra Technologies, SIMULIA, Risk Management Solutions, Brigham Young University, SRD, HRL

Buyer's Guide

HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork

September 2025

Free Report: HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork

Find out what your peers are saying about HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork and other solutions. Updated: September 2025.

DOWNLOAD NOW

868,787 professionals have used our research since 2012.

See our HCL AppScan vs. Klocwork report.

See our list of best Application Security Tools vendors and best Static Application Security Testing (SAST) vendors.

We monitor all Application Security Tools reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.