SmartBear TestComplete and Visual Studio Test Professional compete in the realm of test automation tools. Based on the comparison, SmartBear TestComplete appears to have an advantage in cross-platform testing and automation capabilities, while Visual Studio Test Professional benefits from deep integration with Microsoft’s ecosystem.
Features: SmartBear TestComplete offers robust automation with dynamic find methods, an effective Object Browser for object identification, and cross-platform testing for web and desktop applications. It supports multiple scripting languages enabling data-driven testing and integrates with third-party tools. Visual Studio Test Professional excels with integration into Microsoft's ecosystem, supporting C# and .NET projects, and features IntelliSense and ReSharper to enhance the development process.
Room for Improvement: TestComplete's web and mobile testing frameworks could be improved for user-friendliness, and the licensing process is noted as cumbersome. There is also room for enhancement in language support and error handling. Visual Studio Test Professional faces criticism over pricing and a need for stronger integration with third-party databases. Improvements are also suggested for deployment speed and intuitive error handling.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: Both products offer flexible deployment options, on-premises and in cloud environments. SmartBear TestComplete has received mixed reviews on customer service, with some reports of delayed responses, while Visual Studio Test Professional is generally praised for satisfactory service, though technical support may be occasionally lacking.
Pricing and ROI: SmartBear TestComplete is seen as costly due to its modular licensing structure, though users note a significant ROI through time savings. Pricing for Visual Studio Test Professional is also considered high, especially for enterprise licenses, yet the comprehensive features offer flexibility, including a community version that serves smaller teams.
Once set up, only one person is needed to handle all tasks, reducing the requirement for multiple personnel.
Sometimes, the documentation is not readable, being too long or too detailed and not connected to my problem.
While using SmartBear TestComplete, we are fine with the current capabilities, however, it would be beneficial to improve some performance aspects, especially the image comparison feature.
Sometimes, the library version is not compatible with other libraries, causing errors in my application.
The product needs contextual help integrated within its interface.
Additionally, in Visual Studio Code, we have an agent mode for GitHub Copilot, which is very helpful in testing or development phases, while Visual Studio's GitHub Copilot is a bit tricky and sometimes does not provide my desired output.
The price is expensive.
The most valuable feature of SmartBear TestComplete for me is the image comparison functionality.
It supports cross-platform functionality.
We have a retrospective in our auto projects that we are using frequently to get lessons learned, what went well, and what is going wrong.
Visual Studio Test Professional is highly valuable because it provides extensive extensions and plugins that assist in measuring code quality.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| SmartBear TestComplete | 5.0% |
| Visual Studio Test Professional | 2.0% |
| Other | 93.0% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 23 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 19 |
| Large Enterprise | 32 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 15 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 14 |
| Large Enterprise | 24 |
SmartBear TestComplete offers automation testing across desktop, web, and mobile platforms with robust object identification and cross-browser compatibility. It features seamless integration with CI tools and supports diverse tech stacks, enhancing efficiency through modular testing and data-driven capabilities.
SmartBear TestComplete is known for its Object Browser and Object Spy, providing deep inspection and interaction within applications. It supports third-party tool integration, particularly CI platforms, enhancing testing consistency through name mapping and modular testing. Despite its high pricing and need for enhancement in COM and ActiveX support and mobile testing, it offers record-and-playback features, self-healing capabilities, and cross-browser compatibility, making it a choice for regression and automation. Users leverage it for testing in environments including Windows, with exploration into a Flutter-based mobile context. Improvements are desired in object mapping, headless testing, and programming language support, while challenges exist in UI usability and virtual machine licensing.
What are the key features of SmartBear TestComplete?SmartBear TestComplete is implemented in industries requiring comprehensive testing solutions, including those performing regression and functionality testing across platforms. Its integration and behavior automation support CI/CD pipelines, while desktop, web, and mobile applications are tested for UI automation and backend database functionality, showing its adaptability to industry-specific needs.
Visual Studio Test Professional offers sophisticated testing capabilities with a focus on integration with Azure DevOps. Supporting software development, it aids in application creation, lifecycle management, and testing, accommodating a wide array of programming languages.
Visual Studio Test Professional delivers robust features essential for software developers, including seamless integration with C# and .NET projects and extensive customization options. The platform's robust debugging, unit testing, and memory analysis help streamline the development process. Its intuitive interface and integration with tools like IntelliSense and NuGet package manager enhance productivity, alongside its collaboration capabilities with Azure DevOps. While beneficial, it faces challenges such as integration issues with CI tools, high technical skill requirements, and concerns about pricing and stability. Refinements in user interface design, platform compatibility, and support for AI and machine learning technologies remain necessary.
What are the most important features of Visual Studio Test Professional?Visual Studio Test Professional finds its application in software development and automation testing industries, where technical teams use it to create and manage applications across multiple environments. It supports test-driven development, ensuring secure and functional project outputs, and aids in the integration of DevOps practices, enhancing collaborative efforts in software solutions creation.
We monitor all Functional Testing Tools reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
